Differences between PEO and Staffing - Pros, Cons and More
Tarmack LogoRequest a demo

PEOs vs Staffing Companies

September 26, 2023 | Jessica Wisniewski

PEOs vs Staffing Companies

Navigating the World of Workforce Solutions

In the complex landscape of the business world, organizations and business owners face various kinds of challenges when it comes to managing their workforce. From compliance with ever-changing labor laws to the specific needs, aspirations, and payroll processing of employees, the burden of HR and administrative tasks can be overwhelming for any organization. In this situation, workforce solutions providers come to provide you with a helping hand.

The key differences between PEOs and staffing companies mostly depend on their Employment Relationship with the organization, Services they Provide, and Risk Management. They are actually two different types of HR outsourcing services that can help businesses manage their workforce with ease. Each has its own advantages and disadvantages, and the choice between them depends on your specific needs and the priorities of your business organization.

While both serve essential roles, they cater to distinct needs and aspirations of your business. In this blog, we’ll delve into the differences between PEOs and Staffing Companies, helping you understand which solution aligns best with your specific requirements.

Professional Employer Organizations (PEOs)

A PEO is an entity that enters into a co-employment relationship with a client. It, in real sense, becomes the employer of record for tax and insurance purposes, effectively taking on many of the HR and administrative tasks on behalf of you. This allows the client, that is you, to focus more on your core business functions while the PEO takes care of HR responsibilities such as payroll processing, benefits administration, workers’ compensation, and compliance with employment laws.

  • Employment Relationship: PEOs establish a co-employment relationship with their clients. This means that the PEO becomes the employer of record for certain purposes, such as payroll and benefits administration, while the client remains the employer for day-to-day management and operational decisions.
  • Services Provided: PEOs offer a comprehensive suite of HR services, including payroll processing, employee benefits administration, compliance management, risk management, and often, HR consulting. They become deeply integrated into their clients’ HR functions.
  • Ownership of Employees: PEOs share responsibility for employees with their client companies. They may handle payroll, benefits, and related HR functions, but clients retain control over day-to-day work assignments and management of their employees.
  • Risk Management: PEOs often assist clients with managing HR-related risks, such as workers’ compensation, employee disputes, and compliance with labor laws. They share some of the risk with their clients.

Benefits of Opting for PEOs

  • Compliance and HR Expertise: PEOs typically have HR experts who can assist with compliance, payroll processing, tax administration, and benefits management. This can be particularly helpful for small and medium-sized businesses that lack in-house HR expertise.
  • Cost Savings: By pooling together multiple clients’ employees, PEOs can often negotiate better rates for employee benefits like health insurance and retirement plans, potentially resulting in cost savings for clients.
  • Cost Efficiency: PEOs pool multiple client companies together, creating economies of scale. This enables smaller businesses to access benefits and HR services at a lower cost than they could achieve on their own.
  • Expertise: PEOs are well-versed in HR, compliance, and especially labor laws. They can help businesses navigate the complex laws, regulations, and reduce the risk of non-compliance.
  • Access to Benefits: PEOs often offer a comprehensive benefits package, including health insurance, retirement plans, and other perks, making it easier for clients to attract and retain top talent.
  • Time Savings: Outsourcing HR tasks to a PEO frees up valuable time for business owners and managers to focus on strategic initiatives and core competencies.

However, it’s important to note that while PEOs handle many HR functions, they do not typically provide temporary or contract staffing solutions. This is where Staffing Companies come into play.

Staffing Companies

Staffing Companies, also known as staffing agencies or employment agencies, primarily focus on sourcing and providing temporary or contract workers to client companies. These workers may be needed for specific projects, seasonal demands, or to cover staff absences. Staffing Companies maintain a pool of candidates with various skills and qualifications, matching them with the specific needs of their client businesses.

  • Employment Relationship: Staffing Companies typically do not establish a co-employment relationship with their clients. They provide temporary or contract workers to their clients on a short-term basis.
  • Services Provided: Staffing Companies primarily focus on recruiting and providing temporary or contract employees to their clients. They may handle aspects like screening, interviewing, and onboarding of temporary workers.
  • Ownership of Employees: Staffing Companies retain ownership of the employees they place with their clients. These employees work at the client’s location but are considered employees of the staffing company.
  • Risk Management: Staffing Companies usually retain more of the risk associated with the employees they provide, including workers’ compensation and legal liability for the temporary workers.

Benefits of Opting for Staffing Companies

  • Flexibility: Staffing companies provide temporary, contract, or temp-to-hire employees, allowing businesses to quickly adjust their workforce to changing needs and demand.
  • Specialized Talent: Staffing agencies often have access to a pool of specialized talent, making it easier to find skilled workers for specific roles.
  • Reduced Administrative Burden: Businesses can offload many HR administrative tasks, such as recruitment, onboarding, and payroll, to the staffing agency.
  • Specialized Talent: These agencies often specialize in specific industries or job types, ensuring that clients receive workers with the right skill sets for their projects.

Drawbacks of Choosing Staffing Companies

  • Higher Labor Costs: The cost of hiring temporary or contract workers can be higher on an hourly basis compared to full-time employees, especially if specialized skills are required.
  • Less Long-Term Commitment: While staffing agencies offer flexibility, they may not always be suitable for businesses looking to build a stable, long-term workforce.
  • Recruitment Challenges: Finding the right temporary or contract workers can be time-consuming, and the quality of candidates may vary.

In Summary..

So, PEOs and staffing companies offer different solutions for managing a workforce. While PEOs and Staffing Companies serve different functions, some companies may find value in utilizing both, depending on their staffing needs and HR requirements. For example, a company might engage a PEO to manage its core workforce while partnering with a Staffing Company to fill temporary or project-based roles.

PEOs are best suited for those seeking comprehensive HR support, while Staffing Companies are ideal for businesses requiring temporary or contract workers. By leveraging the strengths of each, companies can optimize their workforce management strategies, allowing them to focus on what they do best—driving growth and innovation in their respective industries.

Ultimately, the choice between PEOs and Staffing Companies should align with an organization’s unique goals and workforce requirements.

A truly global HR platform with everything you need to build, grow & manage a global team.

  • bestTalentIdentifying & recruiting the best talent
  • payrollPayroll with full compliance across 100+ countries
  • agreementsEmployment agreements as per local laws
  • contractorContractor invoices & time management
  • onboardingSmooth remote onboarding of employees
  • immigrationImmigration & mobility services around the world
Find Out More